Ok, It's me again, just wanted to let you know Alice Books accepted my resubmission.
So here's a quick recap of everything for those just reading this post and ordering from Alice Books:
You should get a confirmation email within one business day (mon-fri) on your order.
If you mess something up, no email.
Subject line isn't all that important, add "Order", "Order Flows", or something like that if you want.
Follow a format like this if you're unsure about the body of the email:
different item's URL
If you're curious on what went wrong with my order originally, it was probably the formatting.